An Impossible task

Essay by Séan Padraic Birnie

Before her lover departs, she traces his shadow, thrown by candelight, on to the wall.
Later her father, the potter Butades, will make a cast from the drawing.


In the Natural History, Pliny locates the origins of art, of the graphic and plastic arts, in the trauma of romantic loss. As a way of staving off a future loss and as a form of compensation once it has passed. The question of contact and of touching plays a determinate part in proceedings: the present lover directly casts his shadow; the young woman directly traces his shadow; her father fashions his sculpture directly from the trace. A certain connection threads through each medial layer. So art begins with the shadow of its subject, its ghost or shade, a derivative effect. Something primary and vital is lost; the work of art exists in a condition of secondarity, surrogacy, derivation. The myth establishes the question of medium, too, of the limitations that enable and disable in unequal measure: sculpture, which takes drawing as its model; and how the shift into three dimensions from the original tracing becomes a more powerful invocation of presence. In this sculpture fulfills a promise that drawing makes but cannot honour. It becomes something you can touch. It becomes something you can hold, and thereby compensates, or for a time seems to compensate, for the inadequacy of the two-dimensional image. It replaces the shadow of the man with the shadow of the sculpture. The sculpture, as the fulfillment of this process, as a tactile thing occupying space in the world, becomes a surrogate for the lover and the lost sensuality of love.

But in its fulfillment of that promise it risks a deeper betrayal: the truest likeness becomes the greatest travesty. Instead of summoning that presence, it casts the absence into sharp relief. What aspired to compensate becomes a taunt. The likeness simulates presence, but in the very efficacy of its simulation throws a harsh light on the facts of distance and future-loss. Photography, in which the automatic apparatus secures a form of homological likeness unparalleled in the other depictive arts, exacerbates this logic. Every photograph is this catastrophe, as Barthes says of the picture of Lewis Payne, shortly before his execution. For the Hungarian photographer Brassaï “...the question is always to find that sole translation that will be valid in another language... for all literal translation is treason.” The medium’s fidelity to surfaces enables the illusion that one might enter the picture, that the image plane hoards depth, forever just out of reach. The desires photography sets in motion (and the very desire which set photography into motion) animate the belief in that illusion (and we know it is an illusion, of course, we are not naive: nevertheless, the precision secures our belief, in spite of that knowledge), which works only at a certain distance: nose against print or screen, the image breaks up, becomes grain or noise. Becomes a hard surface. What at first seems to put you into touch becomes at last a barrier.

In photographs and partial sculptures, Beheld explores these barriers. One might go further and say that the essence of the work does not reside in the individual pieces, but in their interrelationships, and in the primary relationship Beheld supplants, that of lover and the beloved, artist and subject. The work finds its starting point and aesthetic logic in the myth of the Corinthian maid. Tease out the meanings that its title set in play: to hold and to touch, most obviously. To possess and be possessed; the eye of the beholder (and the failure of photography’s optical regime), a later addition in English to the Germanic compound. In relation to its combination of different media, the way a medium holds, or tries to hold, its subject. The term always contains this sense of potential loss: one only need hold on to something that can be taken away. Hold still – like a sculpture – for a photograph. Hold back. Contain, like a frame, or like a medium. That containment necessarily fails, and it is this failure that seems to me to be the key to the way that Beheld works. The subject – any subject – will always exceed its form: the translation of which Brassaï speaks is always an abstraction, a reduction. There is no lossless medium. Condemned to an impossible task, the problem becomes one of doing justice to the subject, to the subject’s overflowing excess: in the interstices between its components – digital photographs on tracing paper; a sculpture in marble dust; stills from an unshown video recording the attempt to draw a perfect circle – that excess returns in spectral from: a product of spatial relationships, of incomplete processes, unfinished things. That form does not become visible or tangible, and in this way it eludes the violence of reduction. Instead it hovers in the gaps.

The likeness in marble dust is from a direct mold of the subject’s face (Andre Bazin likens photograph to a death mask, molded from that face). It’s a temporary sculpture, reformed for every showing. The delicacy of the thing solicits the desire to touch, but of course to touch it would be to destroy the likeness, would dislodge its precarious shape. Like a reflection in water – touch the surface and the splash disrupts the image. In a reversal of the shift, in the Corinthian Maid myth, from the graphic image to the plastic form, the sculpture in its turn becomes the subject of a photograph, fixing that precarity in the stillness of the picture. It is a photograph of the sculpture, but not of this sculpture, the one here on the floor, but an earlier point in the series of temporary sculptures made for each showing of the work. Possibly the original sculpture, though what status accrues to an original is rather thrown into question. But in the studio now the two works, sculpture and photograph, photograph of an earlier form of the present sculpture, vie for primacy in a struggle without resolution. Perhaps that irresolution in itself is the point: this skein of mediations, from body to shadow to tracing to cast to sculpture – when the lover departs, only this tangle of shadows and shadows of shadows remains.

This essay features work by James William Murray:

Comments (522)

  1. Pingback: curadebt reviews bbb

  2. Pingback:

  3. Pingback: Camille

  4. Pingback: new york seo

  5. Pingback: 這是一個騙局,避免這是一個騙局,避免這是一個騙局,避免這是一個騙局,避免

  6. Pingback: Ninja Smoke Bombs

  7. Pingback: Gianna

  8. Pingback: Replica rolex copy watch paypal

  9. Pingback:

  10. Pingback:

  11. Pingback:

  12. Pingback:

  13. Pingback:

  14. Pingback:

  15. Pingback:

  16. Pingback:

  17. Pingback:

  18. Pingback:

  19. Pingback:

  20. Pingback:

  21. Pingback:

  22. Pingback:

  23. Pingback:

  24. Pingback:

  25. Pingback:

  26. Pingback:

  27. Pingback:

  28. Pingback:

  29. Pingback:

  30. Pingback:

  31. Pingback:

  32. Pingback:

  33. Pingback:

  34. Pingback: check this link right here now

  35. Pingback:

  36. Pingback: Dentist in Claremont California

  37. Pingback: แทงบอลสเต็ป

  38. Pingback: How To Make FREE Money Online From PayPal

  39. Pingback: Replica rolex clone for sale

  40. Pingback: used trucks dealership winnipeg

  41. Pingback: 카지노싸이트 【 CGV123.COM 】

  42. Pingback: 안전놀이터

  43. Pingback: San Diego Domestic Violence Lawyer

  44. Pingback: meme champ

  45. Pingback: hedge trimmer

  46. Pingback: house moving company

  47. Pingback: trusted online casino malaysia

  48. Pingback: efcaxdszdfszgd

  49. Pingback: m980u9oy9y98o8y9pm

  50. Pingback: m90uojmuy7hjhhhh

  51. Pingback: rxc43rw435tr53t453t


  53. Pingback: book holiday taxi

  54. Pingback: Wall Tapestry

  55. Pingback: cxqw234xracrwcr4

  56. Pingback: xdsffx4crta4rtxa34w

  57. Pingback: uscojufm9r4tue4urtse4

  58. Pingback: karlsruhe

  59. Pingback: chương trình định cư canada

  60. Pingback:

  61. Pingback:

  62. Pingback:

  63. Pingback:

  64. Pingback: royal cbd

  65. Pingback:

  66. Pingback:

  67. Pingback:

  68. Pingback: royal cbd

  69. Pingback: buy cbd oil

  70. Pingback: royal cbd oil

  71. Pingback: mitrade lua dao

  72. Pingback: generic cialis buy

  73. Pingback: Maria Anderson

  74. Pingback: 메리트카지노 사이트

  75. Pingback: buy levitra online

  76. Pingback: canada pharmacy canada pharmacy

  77. Pingback: mega888 original

  78. Pingback:

  79. Pingback: skin care products canada

  80. Pingback: 메리트카지노 추천

  81. Pingback: order cialis in australia

  82. Pingback: proven side effects

  83. Pingback: cialis 5 mg generico

  84. Pingback: generic viagra brands

  85. Pingback: 5 second water hack

  86. Pingback: phim sex online

  87. Pingback: help writing an argumentative essay

  88. Pingback: golfing sunglasses

  89. Pingback: cialis price

  90. Pingback: cialis buy

  91. Pingback: cialis vs levitra

  92. Pingback: tadalafil for sale

  93. Pingback: värdera klocka

  94. Pingback: buy viagra online cheap

  95. Pingback: how to use viagra

  96. Pingback: generic viagra india

  97. Pingback: how does viagra work

  98. Pingback: silencil scam

  99. Pingback: kadikoy escort

  100. Pingback: brokerreview scam

  101. Pingback: download joker123

  102. Pingback: Revenge

  103. Pingback: sàn forex

  104. Pingback: online transcription service

  105. Pingback: Prandin

  106. Pingback: taxi account

  107. Pingback: Apartemen bsd

  108. Pingback: supplements

  109. Pingback: website

  110. Pingback: sisteme de copiat

  111. Pingback: top 10 sàn forex uy tín

  112. Pingback: watch movies online pk

  113. Pingback: best family movies on amazon prime

  114. Pingback: detectives privados murcia

  115. Pingback: Home Appliances

  116. Pingback: cara main 918kiss untuk menang

  117. Pingback: Drucker mieten für das Büro

  118. Pingback: Aaron Lal

  119. Pingback: Aaron Lal

  120. Pingback: my mega888 dragon

  121. Pingback:

  122. Pingback: Adam Robinson Bendigo

  123. Pingback: Sadye Evins

  124. Pingback: malaysia mega888 iphone

  125. Pingback: ecommerce

  126. Pingback: human hair

  127. Pingback: 13x6 lace front wigs

  128. Pingback: lace wigs

  129. Pingback: ラブドール

  130. Pingback: mega888 website login

  131. Pingback: Check This Out

  132. Pingback: 34cr4rxq3crq34rq3r4

  133. Pingback: download mega888 youtube

  134. Pingback: Julian Di Benedetto

  135. Pingback: payroll services singapore

  136. Pingback: Kingpen

  137. Pingback: Buy Weed Online

  138. Pingback: stray kids merchandise

  139. Pingback: buy cialis online in canada

  140. Pingback: c34r54wxw4r34c3

  141. Pingback: buy cheap cialis overnight

  142. Pingback: weight loss diet pills

  143. Pingback: lose weight fast

  144. Pingback: galaforex

  145. Pingback: twitter login with apple

  146. Pingback: hold'em

  147. Pingback: buy cialis united kingdom

  148. Pingback: kienthucfx

  149. Pingback: poker hand

  150. Pingback: silencil medical reviews

  151. Pingback: cheap generic cialis

  152. Pingback: dana white

  153. Pingback: cotton bras plus size

  154. Pingback: truck battery

  155. Pingback: cut files

  156. Pingback: Read More Here

  157. Pingback: t-shirts women

  158. Pingback: play roulette online

  159. Pingback: renovation

  160. Pingback: investir dans du neuf

  161. Pingback:

  162. Pingback: romantic night at home

  163. Pingback: Discover More Here

  164. Pingback: cbd oil for dogs

  165. Pingback: cialis online without prescription

  166. Pingback: best cbd for dogs

  167. Pingback: best cbd oil for depression

  168. Pingback: best cbd gummies

  169. Pingback: best cbd oil

  170. Pingback: best guinea pig cage

  171. Pingback: family

  172. Pingback: Gene Vihodsef

  173. Pingback: astronomy for kids

  174. Pingback: GST billing software

  175. Pingback: sculpture

  176. Pingback: where can i buy cialis without a prescription

  177. Pingback: roof box for car

  178. Pingback: best cbd gummies

  179. Pingback: kpop clothes

  180. Pingback: buy cbd gummies

  181. Pingback: cbd

  182. Pingback: cbd dog treats

  183. Pingback: best cbd dog treats

  184. Pingback: buy instagram followers

  185. Pingback: best cbd oils for pain

  186. Pingback: best cbd gummies for sleep

  187. Pingback: best cbd dog treats

  188. Pingback: cbd gummies for sleep

  189. Pingback: cbd for dogs

  190. Pingback: best cbd dog treats

  191. Pingback: cbd oil

  192. Pingback: best cbd gummies for pain

  193. Pingback: anxiety

  194. Pingback: understanding hockey betting lines

  195. Pingback: cost of tadalafil without insurance

  196. Pingback: IPTV provider

  197. Pingback: 토토커뮤니티

  198. Pingback: realistic sex doll

  199. Pingback: Geruson

  200. Pingback:

  201. Pingback: Crypto

  202. Pingback: vragen

  203. Pingback: compare free alternative remote team management tools

  204. Pingback: 강남 안마

  205. Pingback:

  206. Pingback: Puppies Orlando

  207. Pingback:

  208. Pingback: 강남 안마

  209. Pingback: 강남안마

  210. Pingback: kerala nursing council registration renewal phone number

  211. Pingback: loans

  212. Pingback: moj dom sulecin

  213. Pingback: luxury and watches

  214. Pingback: Ben marks Mackay

  215. Pingback: kratom powder

  216. Pingback: kratom capsules for sale

  217. Pingback: kratom tea for sale

  218. Pingback:

  219. Pingback: giaodichforex scam

  220. Pingback: pussy888 original 2021

  221. Pingback: new and used tires surrey

  222. Pingback: canada website

  223. Pingback: Eli Dangerfield

  224. Pingback: Hottest Crypto 10000x safemoon.......

  225. Pingback: pet supply store

  226. Pingback: miroitier paris

  227. Pingback:

  228. Pingback: occult The occult witchcraft magic

  229. Pingback: Enamel pins

  230. Pingback: THC vape juice

  231. Pingback: online cigars

  232. Pingback: ac repair livonia

  233. Pingback: pet supply store

  234. Pingback: best wireless over ear headphones for working out

  235. Pingback: 吸游戏

  236. Pingback: 인싸포커

  237. Pingback: water stockpile for wshtf

  238. Pingback: prima visita dentista torino

  239. Pingback: hire a private investigator UK

  240. Pingback: INSURANCE

  241. Pingback: nails wien

  242. Pingback:

  243. Pingback: como ganar dinero en internet

  244. Pingback:

  245. Pingback: instagram takipçi satın al

  246. Pingback:

  247. Pingback: where to buy delta 8

  248. Pingback: Kamagra

  249. Pingback:

  250. Pingback: Viagra bez recepty

  251. Pingback: delta 8 THC for sale

  252. Pingback: how to earn cryptocurrency

  253. Pingback: para kazanma

  254. Pingback: Trans Sex Guide

  255. Pingback: professional development training

  256. Pingback: pdtraining

  257. Pingback: discount cialis south africa

  258. Pingback: sildenafil purchase

  259. Pingback: tadalafil tablets canada

  260. Pingback: sildenafil 100mg price usa

  261. Pingback: discount cialis online canada

  262. Pingback: Review and Bonus

  263. Pingback: Celebrity Van Repair Near Me

  264. Pingback: custom tshirts

  265. Pingback: celebrex toxisity dosage

  266. Pingback: keflex side effects in women

  267. Pingback: click

  268. Pingback: what is keflex antibiotic

  269. Pingback: read more

  270. Pingback: duloxetine and aloieve

  271. Pingback: duloxetine vs lyrica

  272. Pingback: Like This

  273. Pingback: Like This

  274. Pingback: sildenafil tablets 150mg

  275. Pingback: buy viagra gel online us

  276. Pingback: read my site

  277. Pingback: hardware stores near me

  278. Pingback: acheter viagra sildenafil

  279. Pingback: where can i get cialis australia

  280. Pingback: Click

  281. Pingback: pdt training

  282. Pingback: cheap generic viagra online uk

  283. Pingback: บาคาร่า66

  284. Pingback: JOKER

  285. Pingback: generic cialis 40mg

  286. Pingback: วิปโฟม

  287. Pingback: โฟมล้างหน้าสำหรับผิวแพ้ง่าย

  288. Pingback: sildenafil 100mg sale from india

  289. Pingback: buy cialis over the counter canada

  290. Pingback: buy generic levitra online

  291. Pingback: cialis cost canada free bonus pills

  292. Pingback: บาคาร่า

  293. Pingback: ผลบอลสด

  294. Pingback: สมัคร

  295. Pingback: ทางเข้าsboแทงบอล

  296. Pingback: slotxo

  297. Pingback: generic cialis drugstore

  298. Pingback: เว็บพนัน

  299. Pingback: แทงหวย

  300. Pingback: หวยออนไลน์

  301. Pingback: otc cialis 2018

  302. Pingback: viagra purchase in india

  303. Pingback: read here

  304. Pingback: read here

  305. Pingback: sildenafil 50 mg coupon

  306. Pingback: read here

  307. Pingback: more

  308. Pingback: generic tadalafil 2018

  309. Pingback: more

  310. Pingback: stress management training

  311. Pingback: price for sildenafil 20 mg

  312. Pingback: generic viagra reviews south africa

  313. Pingback: sildenafil mexico

  314. Pingback: wells fargo iso program

  315. Pingback: sildenafil citrate tablets vs viagra

  316. Pingback: viagra reviews reddit south africa

  317. Pingback: click

  318. Pingback: read here

  319. Pingback: more

  320. Pingback: more

  321. Pingback: click

  322. Pingback: Virtual Training

  323. Pingback: Kamagra żel

  324. Pingback: click

  325. Pingback: tabletki na potencję

  326. Pingback: read here

  327. Pingback: damony

  328. Pingback: click

  329. Pingback: check it

  330. Pingback: more

  331. Pingback: buy cialis ebay

  332. Pingback: web design agency uk

  333. Pingback: Zakhar Berkut hd

  334. Pingback: 4569987

  335. Pingback: winsol

  336. Pingback: trenorol

  337. Pingback: order original cialis online

  338. Pingback: order original online

  339. Pingback: news news news

  340. Pingback: Cialis

  341. Pingback:

  342. Pingback: super slot vip เครดิต ฟรี 50

  343. Pingback: where to purchase tretinoin

  344. Pingback: Online betting

  345. Pingback: cheap server hosting

  346. Pingback: canada usa

  347. Pingback: sales funnels

  348. Pingback: payment processing sales

  349. Pingback: how to start a merchant processing company

  350. Pingback: Viagra

  351. Pingback: Ocala

  352. Pingback: become a payment service provider

  353. Pingback: selling merchant services

  354. Pingback: Payment aggregator business model

  355. Pingback:

  356. Pingback: topvideos

  357. Pingback: video

  358. Pingback: Toledo-OH Roofing Service

  359. Pingback: best merchant services companies to work for

  360. Pingback: family

  361. Pingback: Ketqua

  362. Pingback: Open a merchant services company

  363. Pingback: W88

  364. Pingback: W88vnbet

  365. Pingback: buy cheaper online

  366. Pingback: merchant sales agent

  367. Pingback: W88

  368. Pingback: 123Movies

  369. Pingback:

  370. Pingback:

  371. Pingback: Ukrainskie-serialy

  372. Pingback: site

  373. Pingback: best iso agent program

  374. Pingback: credit card processing sales jobs

  375. Pingback: top

  376. Pingback: selling credit card processing

  377. Pingback: taxi

  378. Pingback: laptop recycling

  379. Pingback: start a merchant processing business

  380. Pingback: free computer disposal

  381. Pingback: buy cialis online without a prescription

  382. Pingback: best merchant processing services

  383. Pingback: video

  384. Pingback: it disposal

  385. Pingback: merchant processing agent

  386. Pingback: computer recycling companies

  387. Pingback: satta matka

  388. Pingback: миллион игровой клуб

  389. Pingback: computer recycling companies

  390. Pingback: daftar togel terbaik

  391. Pingback: Exness

  392. Pingback: hospedagem ilimitada

  393. Pingback: slot online

  394. Pingback: Win at Slots

  395. Pingback: hitet me te reja 2021

  396. Pingback: aat ethics

  397. Pingback: Kamagra

  398. Pingback:

  399. Pingback: cialis trial

  400. Pingback: sildenafil 100mg uk

  401. Pingback: daily cialis 5mg

  402. Pingback: cheapest sildenafil india

  403. Pingback:

  404. Pingback: live casino malaysia

  405. Pingback: cialis c5

  406. Pingback: best viagra

  407. Pingback: asbestos removal companies Melbourne

  408. Pingback: browse this site

  409. Pingback: Commercial Outdoor security cameras

  410. Pingback: live oranum

  411. Pingback:

  412. Pingback: laptop disposal near me

  413. Pingback: computer disposal services

  414. Pingback: música para dormir

  415. Pingback: buy Instagram likes

  416. Pingback: best delta 8

  417. Pingback: best delta 8 THC vape cartridges

  418. Pingback: buy real Instagram likes

  419. Pingback: togel hk

  420. Pingback: Food License

  421. Pingback: best delta 8 thc gummies

  422. Pingback: online gamble malaysia

  423. Pingback: nie sme tupi izmamnici

  424. Pingback: led strips guide

  425. Pingback: w88clubvip

  426. Pingback: vaobong88

  427. Pingback: Edibles

  428. Pingback: first data iso program

  429. Pingback: cbd gummies for sale

  430. Pingback: delta 8 THC

  431. Pingback: buy weed near me

  432. Pingback: d2 store

  433. Pingback: share

  434. Pingback: foreclosure fraud

  435. Pingback: Celebrity Life Coach

  436. Pingback: togel online

  437. Pingback: student debt

  438. Pingback: vps server router

  439. Pingback: buy weed

  440. Pingback: Seattle Weekly

  441. Pingback: weed near me

  442. Pingback: dispensary near me

  443. Pingback: buy weed

  444. Pingback: dispensaries near me

  445. Pingback: blog post

  446. Pingback: iptv subscription price

  447. Pingback:

  448. Pingback: Project marketing Sydney

  449. Pingback: s&r cookware sale

  450. Pingback: หวยออนไลน์

  451. Pingback: floor mats for my car

  452. Pingback: muabacklinks

  453. Pingback: roof restoration adelaide

  454. Pingback: Shaun Segal

  455. Pingback: trusted online casino malaysia 2020

  456. Pingback: mesothelioma class action lawsuit

  457. Pingback: โปรแกรมเจ้ามือหวย

  458. Pingback: home removals service

  459. Pingback: باوربوينت

  460. Pingback: affiliate marketing is

  461. Pingback: Satta Matka

  462. Pingback: delta-8 moon rocks

  463. Pingback: Blue Cheese Vape Cartridge (.5g)(gLeaf)

  464. Pingback: xauusd

  465. Pingback: Raag Consultants

  466. Pingback: organic growth instagram service

  467. Pingback: Do love spells work

  468. Pingback: glycerin soap

  469. Pingback: innessimpson

  470. Pingback: Fast Covid Test

  471. Pingback: Dịch Vụ Seo Scam

  472. Pingback: Curbside Delivery

  473. Pingback: Vermisstenbildlisten

  474. Pingback: 321 strong foam roller

  475. Pingback: d2r item shop

  476. Pingback: Bluetooth

  477. Pingback: silk pajamas

  478. Pingback: Victor Metlege

  479. Pingback: Karikatur

  480. Pingback:

  481. Pingback: comprar aceite de oliva

  482. Pingback: comprar aceite de oliva ecologico

  483. Pingback: Great Dane Puppies for sale in Oklahoma

  484. Pingback: silk scarf for hair

  485. Pingback: best adjustable beds

  486. Pingback: is viagra safe for 20 year olds

  487. Pingback: viagra generic online pharmacy

  488. Pingback:

  489. Pingback: satta matka

  490. Pingback: vn88

  491. Pingback: cadovn88

  492. Pingback: w88

  493. Pingback:

  494. Pingback: мтс переводы денег на карту

  495. Pingback: 1gom7m

  496. Pingback: 토토사이트

  497. Pingback: 188live

  498. Pingback:

  499. Pingback:

  500. Pingback: fun888

  501. Pingback: Windows Server 2016 Standard

  502. Pingback: keo bong da

  503. Pingback: nha cai jbo

  504. Pingback: what does amlodipine besylate do

  505. Pingback: His Secret Obsession

  506. Pingback: sbotop123

  507. Pingback: Bartier Perry

  508. Pingback: dog prozac side effects

  509. Pingback: over the counter omeprazole

  510. Pingback: how long until zoloft works

  511. Pingback: quetiapine fumarate price

  512. Pingback: coupon for lyrica

  513. Pingback: how to lose weight on lexapro

  514. Pingback: best time of day to take duloxetine

  515. Pingback: hydrochlorothiazide drug interaction

  516. Pingback: robot trading fahrenheit

  517. Pingback: jbb512

  518. Pingback: Fun78

  519. Pingback:

  520. Pingback:

  521. Pingback: xtb lừa đảo

  522. Pingback: escitalopram para que se usa

Comments are closed.